Forgive me for this untypically opinionated and finger-wagging post. Some of my readers might happen to like McNaughton. We are still friends. Just know that I will never compliment you for hanging him on your wall.
The man's propaganda is, if I may borrow Huxley's term, "herd-poisoning" the people with the artistic aesthetic of a Thomas Kinkade (had Kinkade painted people instead of cozy cottage landscapes).
(At least cozy cottage landscapes aren't offensive, short-sighted, and self-righteous.)
I've also declared war on Glenn Beck, but at least he's mostly a comic strip character. McNaughton is selling his works to be framed over sofas as religious proclamations (which they are most definitely not). Except instead of being inspirational reminders of our own humility and dependence on God, he has created political allegories that blow into flame whatever ignorant opinions are stereotypical of green Jello culture. Doesn't he realize the riskiness of such overt and shameless symbolism? Does he feel no regret at polarizing complex problems, or refusing to suspend his own judgment long enough to consider other viewpoints as valid as his own?
And how are so many good people fine with accepting his interpretations of God, country, and mankind? Have we lost the art of questioning? Do we believe anything we see if it's been painted with soft lighting, contains familiar faces, and sold at a Deseret Book?
Enough! Propaganda is not art! It's delusive and breeds fear and prejudice. It does not inspire community or brotherhood or self-examination, but rather it builds walls between neighbors and promotes self-congratulation.
I declare war on you, Jon McNaughton. I'm disappointed that a man with access to so much light and knowledge still hasn't learned what it means to think before mass-producing disinformation under the guise of religious art. I've seen your latest, and I'm sick from it. I can't sit down about this any longer.
Didn't President Hinckley teach us that, "There is too much intolerance in the world. There is too much of it in our own society"? In his essay to college students, "Out of Your Experience Here," he says, "How enriched is the individual who, as he or she goes out into the world, knows that all men and women are sons and daughters of God, each endowed with a divine birthright. How beneficial to come to the realization that, since we are all children of God, we all are brothers and sisters in a very real sense." So why paint pictures that are going to turn brothers against brothers with stereotyping and the slandering of people from Charles Darwin to President Obama? Your images are nothing but straw men, but the people look to your work as if you've paved them in brick. Have you no conscience?
If you want to draw a political cartoon, draw one. Make a statement. But don't tout your opinions as if they were gospel. Don't sell them into homes on the premise that it will make their dwellings holy.
I declare war on you, Jon McNaughton.
17 comments:
AMEN! (As I'm typing this, Julie Andrews is crooning "My Favorite Things" on Pandora. How poetic and ironic.
And let's add a little end parenthesis, shall we?)
Jade! I'm so glad you've joined the ranks! (And Julie Andrews can come with us.)
I'm in, but am confused about uniforms. Initially I was thinking splatters a la Polluck, but then I thought that would contrast too much with McNaughton. Pastel colors perhaps?
I went to his site to see his latest, which is nasty. The thing that really got me is his stupid defense of Arizona law.
I. can't. agree. more.
It. is. the. WORST.
Adding to my "things I don't love" list. now.
I like you a lot. I think you will like this:
original with java script descriptions: http://www.mcnaughtonart.com/artwork/view_zoom/?artpiece_id=353#
parody that rocks hard core with java script descriptions: http://420.thrashbarg.net/one-nation-under-god-usa-mcnaughton-fine-art-shortpacked-parody.html
Emily,
I'm simultaneously your blog-stalker and vicarious friend (you're familiar with my wife, Becca). Anyway, thanks for the great post. My parents have one of these paintings in their house (bless their hearts)and I cringed severely when I first saw it, but I could never have expressed my distaste better, or as well, as you have here. When I read this I have that rare feeling of satisfaction combined with a tinge of jealousy that I was not so articulate when I first encountered the phenomenon which is Jon McNaughton.
Have you seen Seth Smith's newly released video? Check it out on youtube:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4KGlBHyVeYU
....thoughts?
Tarra: *giggling and giggling* that is a gem of a parody. I can't wait to read through all the captions. The barbershop quartet is too much. Thank you, thank you for that link.
Al: You and Becca are always welcome here, and I'm so glad you can empathize. People I love dearly have hung McNaughton on their walls, too, and my gripe isn't with them. It's with the man who did the painting.
Rachel: The Seth video is what prompted this post. I didn't have the heart to boo his video, so I took out my angst here. My bone to pick is with McNaughton, not Seth.
"the forgotten man"....white middle-class male aged 18-35. No one ever remembers that man.
Ditto, Joe.
I'm such an isolate that I've never heard of this guy, but McNaughton is meanness dripping with rampant sentimentality. I'm stopping at commenting on his intended audience, many of whom he's probably sucking up like a Hoover vacuum. I watched the vid. and felt nausuated.
Emily: Yikes! I didn't know anything about this until now. I googled his images, and they are very disturbing to me--more so for the reasons you said so well--all the well-meaning people who will walk into a Deseret Book and think if it is sold there, it must be good and edifying and praiseworthy.
I truly feel disturbed by this.
Sherry showed me his first painting a while back. I wish I had started the war back then!
(by the way, I like my word verification: dedlysit)
I gotta say, I have no idea what you are talking about. He painted George Washington praying, I'm fine with that, whatev. Then I saw this bloody scroll thing, and I don't know what it means, so, I guess his message is lost on me. But I gotta say, I'm like that with art. It could be wallpaper on a frame and if it is pretty, I like it. Anyway, now I have to go watch these videos because I'm interested in what you are saying about it. Let me know how the war continues.
Alrighty, figured it out. The bloody scroll thing is a riff (Jen, READ the website, don't just look at the pictures!), and I saw the real one. I gotta say, I don't like a single part of it. I find it pretty tacky and misleading. But, you know, I'm all for free speech. Which is why I'm all for your blog.
I ran across your blog investigating the meaning to the lyrics from Muskrat Love -- yes you are right I have nothing to do on a Friday night. But I had to comment on your "war on Jon McNaughton" I was not familiar with any of this but I must admit that we should indeed consider others viewpoints as you said "Does he feel no regret at polarizing complex problems, or refusing to suspend his own judgment long enough to consider other viewpoints as valid as his own?" But at some point in time we have to take a stand for what we believe is right or we are no better than floating sand on a beach.
Delusive? Delusive!?
I'm sure that's not a word, and yet here it is in the dictionary. Delusive?
You aced me!
Post a Comment