Sunday, July 15, 2007

Reasons to Quit Academia

I just got my teaching evaluations back from my last semester of school. Well, hot damn. They were the worst yet. Statistically, I was still above average and given an overall "well done" but the supplemental comments were biting and immature. I'm ready to throw in the hat and take up a secretarial job, one where I can blend into the background and be required of no more creativity than to find different ways to say, "How may I transfer your call?"

Sure, maybe the last semester before graduating is supposed to be tough. Along with teaching two classes of sophomore composition, I was in the middle of revising the final drafts of my thesis and meeting for various defenses (that seemed to only get held between my two classes, requiring me to run across campus). I can blame this on my classes being held in dorm rooms, one room being completely unusable one morning because the door lock had run out of batteries. So we sat in a dim, dingy commons room next to a broken full screen television, underneath movie posters of the most intellectually challenging showcase (Star Trek: Nemesis, Never Been Kissed, Zoolander, Cheaper By the Dozen, I Know What You Did Last Summer). I could blame this on the lack of working dry erase markers, the complete lack of any kind of technology and of broken technology with missing parts I don't realize don't work until after I've wheeled big screen televisions and three foot high speakers across campus to the dorms in a wheelbarrow provided by the media warehouse. I could blame this on one classroom's replacement of erasers with large dirty white rags and a white erase board that actually pressed into the wall as I wrote on it, requiring me to place my other hand on the board to steady my writing area.

But I was optimistic. I knew I wouldn't score as high this semester because my mind really was focused on graduating and filling out all the red tape. But perhaps, after all, I am still too young to be teaching, too immature and too close to the students put in my classes. Yes, it IS difficult to compose myself academically when an old district leader signs up for my class, or his girlfriend signs up the next semester. Ward members who think it will be fun or easy to take my class sign up and label me immoral or disgruntled when I ask them to read essays entitled "Shitty First Drafts" or Tim O'Brien pieces. I do not like finding out I'm dating my students' roommates. I do not like hearing from my roommates that my students want to date me. I do not like having friends tell me they cannot date me because I've been an English teacher to all of their friends.

I get discouraged when one asshole writes in his teaching evaluation, "You drove the point home and were easy on the eyes." I do not like getting other evaluations that end with, "Overall great job, Babe." I am tired and I am finished. Some students plead for an easier workload while others chastise me for making class so mindless and cheap. Some students despise the reading assignments while others remark as an afterthought, "you should have had us read stuff sometimes." Why didn't you give us stricter deadlines? they ask, after I granted them an extension because they begged and begged for an additional weekend. Why all the redundancy about the rhetorical triangle? they ask. It is because your compositions obviously lacked the most simple components and the further I drilled them into your frizzed out, earbudded, selfish minds the better your essays actually became.

The hardest bit of feeling this way towards my classes is that before I know how they truly feel, I really appreciate and enjoy all of them. Yes, these evaluations are the worst I've ever received. But regardless, I really enjoyed my students and tried as well as I could at the time to make class rewarding and interesting. And now I am tired. One idiot a year ago confided in me that when he took my class, he stayed awake by staring at my ass. How the hell am I supposed to engage students in persuasive thesis statements and library research when I am nothing more than a piece of low quality meat to these jerks who ought to know better. I should have taught elementary school. Because at least then I could have avoided these know-it-all 23-year-old boys who just got their trophy wives and learned everything they needed to know on their missions and define their idea of "bringing home the bacon" as undressing their foolish, childish, rambling English instructor in their minds.

And THIS is ALL I will ever say about THAT.

18 comments:

Jaren Watson said...

Relax, Babe. If there was actually anything wrong with sexual harrassment it would be illegal. Just take it as a compliment and don't fight the feeling.

Jaren Watson said...

Poor BT. Look wacko, I'm sure it's very frustrating to be in that situation. Truly, I empathize. On a daily basis I find myself the hapless object of limitless people's wanton desires. Seriously, though, do you think that males in other professions will treat you differently than do your students? As long as you are a woman with a humanoid form and detectable pulse, you are going to attract brainless, slobbering dorks who are constantly scheming to get in your knickers. Sad fact of life. My advice: Transgenderize. It worked for me.

ibid said...

Your frustration is palpable and makes me want to knock some heads.

Grifter said...

Again, the Stubb speaks the truth. Trading academic schmuks for corporate schmuks would be as silly as donning a falmboyant pink dress with built-in pearls, publically. And documenting it with photos.

In my short adjunct experience, I have come across a few instances that callenge my dedication too. I hope the comments you cited are the exception to the rule. Ass-hats abound in the world. There is no question that you are a fine teacher--and you know the adage about pleasing everyone.

Also, to second Darren's thought, I can attack kneecaps if necessary.

Emily G said...

Aw, thanks men. This probably doesn't help whatever feminist cause I have going with this post, but it always does make me feel really warm and safe inside when my friends threaten to beat someone up for me. I suppose it hits at the most primitive Me-Jane, You-Tarzan places of my heart.

I feel a lot more reasonable about it after sleeping on it. Stubb, you're lucky I read you this morning and not last night...another male friend of mine didn't see the problem and told me I should just take the compliment and I might have bit his head off. Did, actually, bite his head off, praying-mantis-style. Oh the regrets of next morning.

And, Joe, you and I both know that the pink nightmare is going to bring nothing but promotion and success for me. Finally I have something to wear at job interviews.

Grifter said...

good work em. and please don't read my last post too closely...the typos come out on monday.

Jaren Watson said...

BT, I'm glad I escaped oral decapitation. You realize I was only kidding, right doll?

Price said...

Yeah . . .

I'm going to take the low road here. I just think you're not fully taking advantage of the opportunity knocking at your door. I've considered becoming a college professor for no reason other than to get a shitty piece of Tim O'Brien's girlfriend. Who says you can't date your students? Not only can you date them, you can manipulate the crap out of them. Really, isn't that what being a teacher is all about?
(The above comment is all subtle sarcasm and should be taken with a grain of salt.)

Emily G said...

BT, luckily for you, I don't think I'd ever have the heart (or the stomach) to bite your head off. Mainly because I think it would result in you staying alive anyway by pouring liquids into your own throat and running around a horrendous, hideous mess like that chicken that survived for an extra 18 months after having HIS head lopped off...

Emily G said...

By BT, I'm actually speaking with Stubb. Monday brings out the typos and identity crises for ME.

Price, I'm glad you were never my student. But I'm quite sure if YOU were MY teacher, I would definitely get an A.

parkinfamily said...

It sounds like you have calmed down a little bit, but it sucks, I know. I remember being so excited to get my teacher evaluations from my second class...you remember the one full of 15 out of control boys...because I thought that I really got to them. Instead, I got a bunch of evaluations telling me that I needed to have more control over the class and that I didn't come off as knowing what I was doing. I was enraged and totally disheartened, and even though I had already bailed on the teaching scene, it still hurt. And then I thought of poor Brother George and the AWFUL reviews that we gave him for a class that he poured his heart and soul into. It was at that moment that I was truly ashamed, and it was also then that I realized how useless student evaluations are. It is human nature to pick out the worst and go with it. Don't be too hard on yourself...I've seen you teach and you are good. Don't give up, office jobs are not what they are cracked up to be.

Emily G said...

Oh.....yeah.....we are really going to pay for all the crap we gave Brother George. But if it makes you feel better, I think Bro. George was semi-oblivious to our sheer angst in that class. Otherwise, I have no idea why he would be so friendly to me when I worked with him at the Steinbeck conference.....he doesn't seem the type to hold grudges or be nice in a bitterly resentful way. He even asked after you and Trev, if I recall.

It's definitely different to look back from the student angle. Teachers really do need to be careful not to let stuff get to them. I remember even Hartvigsen being really anal about student feedback. And dare I bring up the Sis. Hawker result in this crowd.....? Please all of you pact with me now that if I really DON'T get married, that I won't turn into one of those really bitter women that refuses to give a man an A because I personally am not getting any.......

Grifter said...

i just bristled at the "h" name..not Viggy though, mind you.

Jactionary said...

I completely feel your pain. Sometimes they're complete jerks. I just looked at my scores from last semester (same as yours--liked me but were frustrated by the course--thank you Terry/Edwards for just riding on others' works and having us do Rereading America again as opposed to you actually having to work for your money and pick out an actual English text). I was too frustrated (especially considering becaues I'm still teaching that stupid book) to even look at comments. My resume should say "Taught English/History/Social Studies/Pop Culture/Babysitting/Mothering 1010." None of these kids realize the hours we pour into trying to help prepare them for their rest of their college academic careers because they're too busy douching it up--ok, I'm sorry that I care, next time I'll just let you fail instead of trying to help you achieve something a little higher than the substandard education that is NCLB.

Okay, I feel much better now! :)

Emily G said...

Ah, yes, the whole Megan/Robb push for 1010 instructors to rise above the mere composition of the thesis statement and personal narrative and to conquer instead gender/race equality, homosexuality, and religious freedom. A noble cause, to be sure, but I can think of three, no eight 1010 instructors who would offend me to my very brim of existence if I had to participate in a discussion they led on ANY semi-controversial subject.

I won't even get into it here. Robb and Megan were great friends of mine...some of the greatest I formerly thought...and I don't think they foresaw the complete mess they created by forcing teachers without any social training or even, in my opinion, ethical depth or flexibility to lead discussions with classrooms where the loudest people will be the most brash and opinionated and most students will fall below the radar in angry silence. I cringe when I think of the homosexual student who had to listen to two full weeks of Mormons bickering over morality. It's not meant for the composition classroom and it hardly invites a trusting atmosphere. See, look, you got me started.

Emily G said...

Though, I'm not sure it was Terry/Edwards' fault.....I was always under the impression that once a text is chosen, it needs to keep on for three years. I don't think they had a choice.

Anonymous said...

I'm in the middle of a teaching gig right now, Em. I get my evaluations next week. I'll probably come to you for commiseration.

Odd thing I was thinking of. So your blog site is Muskrat Love. I have this line from an old poem. The poem's not great but I remembered it. I'm quoting myself which is lame I know, but the coincidence is a little strange. (If it isn't, just please admit to it.)

And I quote:
"Muskrat Lake,
not a place for love
not even a place for muskrats"

Price said...

how abouts you give me a call about anazazi . . . later today would be good.